What makes manager training different from leadership training

Manager training and leadership training aren't the same thing. And treating them like they are is costing your business and your culture.

Managers need to execute. Leaders need to set direction. The training for each should reflect that reality.

When you send managers to leadership training, they learn strategic concepts they can't apply. When you send leaders to manager training, they sit through delegation workshops they mastered years ago.

Here's what makes them different and why it matters.

Managers focus more on execution, leaders focus more on vision

Managers make sure work gets done well, on time, and according to plan. They turn strategy into action, coordinate daily work and solve operational problems.

Leaders set the direction. They decide where the organization is going, why it matters, and how success will be measured.

Manager training should cover:

• Developmental feedback
• Delegation and empowerment
• Running effective one-on-ones
• Managing team performance
• Emotional intelligence
• Managing change

As managers advance, they need additional competencies like strategic thinking, accountability, career development, alignment and psychological safety. These build on core management skills but are still focused on team execution.

Leadership training should cover:

• Setting strategic direction
• Building organizational vision
• Making decisions with incomplete information
• Influencing without authority
• Driving cultural change
• Thinking long-term

A new manager doesn't need vision-setting workshops. They need to learn how to give feedback without fumbling through difficult conversations. A senior leader doesn't need delegation frameworks. They need to understand how to position the organization for what's coming next.

Managers develop people, leaders develop leaders

Managers are responsible for their team's growth and performance. They coach individuals, address skill gaps, and create conditions for people to do their best work.

Leaders develop other leaders. They identify future leadership talent and build bench strength across the organization.

Manager training focuses on:

• Coaching techniques for improving performance
• Career development conversations
• Creating psychological safety
• Building team capabilities

Leadership training focuses on:

• Identifying high-potential talent
• Creating leadership opportunities
• Succession planning
• Developing strategic thinking in others

Managers need to help individual contributors become better at their jobs. Leaders need to help managers become better leaders.

Managers need tactical skills, leaders need strategic thinking

Managers operate in weeks and months. They plan sprints, manage projects, coordinate resources and hit quarterly targets.

Leaders operate in quarters and years. They anticipate industry shifts, position the organization for future challenges, and make decisions that won't pay off for months or years.

Tactical skills managers need:

• Project management and prioritization
• Resource allocation
• Performance tracking
• Process improvement

Strategic skills leaders need:

• Scenario planning
• Competitive analysis
• Risk assessment
• Strategic decision-making frameworks

Train managers to optimize execution. Train leaders to determine what to execute on.

Managers practice through simulations, leaders learn through case studies

Managers need to practice specific skills before using them. How do you deliver tough feedback? How do you handle a defensive employee?

AI simulations work well for manager training. Managers can practice difficult conversations, try different approaches, and build confidence before having real conversations.

Leaders benefit more from discussing complex scenarios, debating strategic options, and learning from how others handled similar situations.

Manager training should include:

• Role-playing difficult conversations
• Practicing feedback through AI simulations
• Working through real delegation scenarios

Leadership training should include:

• Analyzing strategic decisions and outcomes
• Debating approaches to complex challenges
• Learning from other leaders' experiences

Managers need immediate application, leaders need frameworks

Managers face the same situations repeatedly. They have one-on-ones every week. They give feedback constantly. They delegate daily.

Manager training should prepare them to handle these recurring situations better. When they leave training, they should know exactly what to do differently in their next one-on-one.

Leaders face novel situations. Every strategic decision is different. Every organizational challenge is unique.

Leadership training should give them frameworks for thinking through new problems, not scripts for handling specific situations.

Good manager training delivers:

• Specific techniques to use this week
• Scripts for common difficult conversations
• Step-by-step processes for delegation or feedback
• Checklists for effective one-on-ones

Good leadership training delivers:

• Mental models for strategic thinking
• Frameworks for decision-making under uncertainty
• Ways to analyze competitive positioning
• Approaches to organizational change

The timing matters

Most people need manager training before they need leadership training. Too many organizations send brand new managers to leadership programs when they're still figuring out basic management.

Common progression:

• New managers (0-2 years): Management fundamentals 
• Experienced managers (2-5 years): Add leadership development
• Senior managers (5+ years): Shift toward leadership training
• Executives: Advanced leadership focus

Sending a new manager to a strategic leadership workshop is like teaching someone to run before they can walk. They'll struggle to apply anything because they're still figuring out basic feedback conversations.

Where they overlap

Some skills matter for both managers and leaders: communication, building trust, making decisions, handling difficult conversations, and developing self-awareness.

The difference is in application. Managers use communication to coordinate work. Leaders use communication to inspire and align. Both need it, but they need it for different purposes.

Train these overlapping skills with both audiences, but adjust the examples and application to match their role.

How to structure your development programs

Don't create one "leadership program" for everyone who manages people. Build separate tracks.

Manager development track: Start with core manager competencies: developmental feedback, delegation and empowerment, emotional intelligence, and managing change. As managers progress, add advanced competencies like strategic thinking, accountability, career development, alignment, and psychological safety.

Leadership development track:

• Strategic thinking and planning
• Organizational vision and culture
• Influencing across the organization
• Developing leadership capability in others
• Leading through ambiguity

Use custom manager training programs built around these competencies with live classes from expert instructors. Let managers practice with AI simulations customized for your culture. Provide ongoing learning through Electives Membership where managers can develop skills they choose.

Make it clear which programs are for which audience. A senior leader can benefit from manager training as a refresher, but a new manager forced into leadership training will waste everyone's time.

Why this distinction matters

When you blur the line between manager training and leadership training, you end up with programs that don't serve anyone well. New managers get overwhelmed with strategic concepts they can't use. Senior leaders sit through delegation workshops they mastered years ago.

Clear distinctions lead to better outcomes. Managers who get manager training become better at managing. Leaders who get leadership training become better at leading.

Stop treating these as the same thing. Build development programs that match what each role actually needs.

Your managers will run better teams. Your leaders will make better decisions. And your development budget will drive actual results.

Build competency-based development programs. Explore custom manager training with core and advanced manager competencies, AI simulations for practicing management skills, and Electives Membership for ongoing development.

‍