Skip navigation

Why decision-making is hard: Unlocking the puzzle for managers

Decision-making is critical, challenging… and daunting. Discover the top 4 reasons why.

We are looking down from overhead at a team sitting around a conference table, reviewing data trying to make a decision.We are looking down from overhead at a team sitting around a conference table, reviewing data trying to make a decision.

Table of contents

Insights from Ellen Raim, Founder of People MatterWe focus more on solving than preventing People problems.

Decision-making is critical, challenging… and daunting. 

This blog post looks at the complexities of decision-making, unearthing why it’s so difficult.

Here are the top 4 reasons why decision-making is hard for managers:

1. The challenge of choices

At the heart of every decision lies the challenge of choice.

Managers are often caught in a web of competing interests and under pressure to make the right call in a sea of uncertainty. The fear of making the wrong decision can be paralyzing, considering the stakes involved — team dynamics, project outcomes and organizational growth.

2. Information overload

In the age of information, managers face the paradox of plenty.

Access to vast data should (theoretically) make decisions more accessible, yet it often leads to analysis paralysis. Sifting through data to find what's relevant is akin to finding a needle in a haystack, making decision-making an even more Herculean task.

3. The weight of consequences

Every decision a manager makes has consequences, impacting immediate outcomes while shaping the future of the team and the organization.

The responsibility of affecting careers, morale and company success significantly burdens managers, intensifying the stress and complexity involved in decision-making.

4. Emotional complexity

Managers bring their values, experiences and emotions to every decision. 

Balancing personal biases with the need for objectivity is a tightrope walk, making decisions emotionally charged. This complexity can cloud judgment and complicate decision-making.

Empowering decision-making through manager training

Acknowledging the multifaceted nature of decision-making and training managers to develop their decision-making skills is crucial.

Core competencies for effective decision-making

Effective manager training encompasses a broad spectrum of competencies, from enhancing emotional intelligence to mastering conflict resolution. Training should provide managers with strategies to sift through information efficiently, weigh outcomes judiciously and manage the emotional dimensions of decision-making. Emphasizing practical applications, modern manager training programs enable managers to practice skills in controlled environments, building their confidence and competence.

A supportive learning ecosystem

Beyond individual skills, creating a supportive learning ecosystem where managers can share experiences and insights is invaluable. A learning culture fosters continuous improvement and collaboration, providing managers with a network of peers and mentors to consult when faced with challenging decisions.

The road to decisive leadership

The journey toward becoming a decisive leader capable of navigating the complexities of modern organizational life begins with recognizing the inherent challenges of decision-making. 

By investing in comprehensive manager training, organizations can empower their leaders with the knowledge, skills, and support network needed to make informed, confident decisions. Manager training enhances team dynamics, project success and organizational growth.

Learn live. Adapt faster.

Latest resources

Learn more about creating a culture of learning throughout our resources below.

Celebrating MLK Day by creating equity in the workplace
Electives team
 
Dec 12, 2025

Celebrating MLK Day by creating equity in the workplace

MLK Day is a great time to reflect on the work Reverend King did to promote racial equality – and consider what more needs to be done to create equity for all.
Culture + collaboration
How to rebuild momentum after major change
Electives team
 
Dec 10, 2025

How to rebuild momentum after major change

Rebuild team momentum after layoffs, restructuring or leadership changes. Practical strategies to restore energy, trust and productivity during year-end transitions.
Culture + collaboration
Closing the gap between learning and doing
Electives team
 
Dec 9, 2025

Closing the gap between learning and doing

Learn how to close the gap between learning and doing with practical strategies that drive real behavior change and measurable ROI.
Learning best practices
Why your managers are exhausted (and how to stop the cycle)
Electives team
 
Dec 3, 2025

Why your managers are exhausted (and how to stop the cycle)

New research shows surface acting creates a cycle of exhaustion that kills manager performance. Here's how L&D can break the pattern.
Leadership + management
How to celebrate World Introvert Day at work
Electives team
 
Dec 2, 2025

How to celebrate World Introvert Day at work

Celebrate World Introvert Day by helping introverts feel included at work. Here are simple ways to bring out the best in your introverted employees.
Culture + collaboration
How to celebrate Human Rights Day at work
Electives team
 
Dec 1, 2025

How to celebrate Human Rights Day at work

Human Rights Day provides an opportunity to celebrate the freedoms that the UDHR granted us and raises awareness of how people’s human rights can be violated. How should you celebrate Human Rights Day? We have 3 great ways.
Culture + collaboration

View all posts

ENJOYABLE. EASY. EFFECTIVE.

Learning that works.

With live learning + AI simulations, Electives is a learning platform that makes it easy to design, execute and measure effectiveness.

Request a demo

Request a demo

Learn more

Learn more